The Surrey force consulted with the CPS but in October 2009 decided no prosecution could be brought because the alleged victims would not support police action.
However, Surrey Police did not tell any of them that other complaints had also been made.
The former Top of the Pops presenter is thought to have committed more than 200 offences across 28 police force areas, including 34 rapes.
Three-quarters of his victims were under 18, with 28 alleged victims under 10-years-old.
(Maybe he was a Baptist in a previous life.)